Effectiveness of Ultrasound as a Triage Tool in Ruling out Fractures among Non-Critical Emergency Department Patients
Ultrasound as a Triage Tool to Rule out Fractures
Vol. 10 No. 2 : 2015 (103-111)
Abstract
The popularity of ultrasound for acute diagnosis of fractures in the Emergency Department (ED) has increased over the recent years. This present study aimed to determine the sensitivity and specificity of ultrasound use for detection of fractures in a different environment, which is at the triage area of the ED. We compared the results of bedside ultrasound in detecting non-critical fractures to the current gold standard of X-rays in the triage area. The design was a single centered cross-sectional study. From August 2014 till November 2014, a total of 46 patients were recruited, creating 75 image pairs. Following consent, a bedside ultrasound was performed and subsequently compared with X-ray reporting regarding the presence or absence of fractures. SPSS analysis was used to determine the sensitivity and specificity of ultrasound in diagnosing fracture as compared to X-rays. Ultrasound had a sensitivity of 72% (95% CI, 50.6% - 87.9%) and a specificity of 80% (95%CI: 66.3 – 90%) when compared to X-rays in fracture diagnosis. The kappa analyses showed moderate inter observer agreement (0.5) between ultrasound and X-rays in diagnosing fractures. This study suggests that the use of ultrasound as a triage tool yet has unacceptable sensitivity and needs further evaluation and consideration.
Keywords :
emergency,
fractures,
triage,
ultrasound,
Correspondance Address
Nik Azlan Nik Muhamad, Department of Emergency Medicine, Faculty of Medicine,Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia Medical Centre, Jalan Yaacob Latif, Bandar Tun Razak, 56000 Cheras, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Tel: +603-91455702 Fax: +603-91456577 Email: nikazlanmuhamad@hotmail.com
References
Australian College for Emergency Medicine. 2013. Guidelines on the implementation of the Australasian Triage Scale in Emergency Department. Melbourne: ACEM. http://www.bhi.nsw.gov.au [November 2013]
Barata, I., Spencer, R., Suppiah, A., Raio, C., Ward, M.F., Sama, A. 2013. Integrated medical school ultrasound: development of an ultrasound vertical curriculum. Crit Ultrasound J 5(1): 6.
Barata, I., Spencer, R., Suppiah, A., Raio, C., Ward, M.F., Sama, A. 2012. Emergency ultrasound in the detection of pediatric long-bone fractures. Pediatr Emerg Care 28(11): 1154-7.
Bitschnau, R., Gehmacher, O., Kopf, A., Scheier, M., Mathis, G. 1997. Ultrasound diagnosis of rib and sternum fractures. Ultraschall Med 18(4): 158-61.
Blankstein, A. 2011. Ultrasound in the diagnosis of clinical orthopedics: The orthopedic stethoscope. World J Orthop 2(2): 13–24.
Busse, J.W., Kaur, J., Mollon, B., Bhandari, M., Tornetta, P., Schünemann, H.J., Guyatt, G.H. 2009. Low intensity pulsed ultrasonography for fractures: systematic review of randomised controlled trials. BMJ 338: b351.
Chmiel, C., Huber, C.A., Rosemann, T., Zoller, M., Eichler, K., Sidler, P., Senn, O., 2011. Walk-ins seeking treatment at an emergency department or general practitioner out-of-hours service: a cross-sectional comparison, BMC Health Serv Res 11: 94.
Coleman, P., Irons, R., Nicholl, J., 2001. Will alternative immediate care services reduce demands for non-urgent treatment at accident and emergency? Emerg Med J 18(6): 482-7.
Cooke, M.W., Arora, P., Mason, S. 2003. Discharge from triage: modelling the potential in different types of emergency department. Emerg Med J 20(2): 131–3.
Cross, K.P. 2011. Bedside ultrasound for pediatric long bone fractures. Clin Pediatr Emerg Med 12: 27-36.
Fenkl, R., von Garrel, T., Knaepler, H. 2012.Emergency diagnosis of sternum fracture with ultrasound. Unfallchirurg 95(8): 375-9.
Friedrich, R.E., Heiland, M., Bartel-Friedrich, S. 2003. Potentials of ultrasound in the diagnosis of midfacial fractures. Clin Oral Investig 7(4): 226-9.
Hedelin, H., Goksör, L.A., Karlsson, J., Stjernström, S., 2013. Ultrasound-assisted triage of ankle trauma can decrease the need for radiographic imaging. Am J Emerg Med 31(12): 1686–9.
Heyworth, J. 2003. Ottawa ankle rules for the injured ankle. BMJ 326(7386): 405-6.
Javadrashid, R., Khatoonabad, M., Shams, N., Esmaeili, F., Jabbari Khamnei, H. 2011. Comparison of ultrasonography with computed tomography in the diagnosis of nasal bone fractures. Dentomaxillofac Radiol 40(8): 486-91.
Kish, L. 1965. Survey Sampling. New York: John Wiley and Sons; 36.
Law, J., Macbeth, P.B. 2011. Ultrasound: from Earth to Space. Mcgill J Med 13(2): 59.
Lee, J.C., Healy, J. 2004. Sonography of Lower Limb Muscle Injury. AJR Am J Roentgenol 182(2): 341-51.
Lindelius, A., Törngren, S., Sondén, A., Pettersson, H., Adami, J. 2008. Impact of surgeon-performed ultrasound on diagnosis of abdominal pain. Emerg Med J 25(8): 486–91.
Marshburn, T.H., Legome, E., Sargsyan, A., Li, S.M., Noble, V.A., Dulchavsky, S.A., Sims, C., Robinson, D. 2004. Goal-directed ultrasound in the detection of long-bone fractures. J Trauma 57(2): 329–32.
Pian, L., Gillman, L.M., McBeth, P.B., Xiao, Z., Ball, C.G., Blaivas, M., Hamilton, D.R., Kirkpatrick, A.W. 2013. Potential use of remote telesonography as a transformational technology in underresourced and/or remote settings. Emerg Med Int 2013: 986160.
Sippel, S., Muruganandan, K., Levine, A., Shah, S. 2011. Review article: Use of ultrasound in the developing world. Int J Emerg Med 4: 72.
Sites, B.D., Antonakakis. J.G. 2009. Ultrasound guidance in regional anesthesia: state of the art review through challenging clinical scenarios. Local Reg Anesth 2: 1–14.
Stiell, I.G., Greenberg, G.H., McKnight, R.D., Nair, R.C., McDowell, I., Worthington, J.R. 1992. A study to develop clinical decision rules for the use of radiography in acute ankle injuries. Ann Emerg Med 21(4): 384–90.
Warkentine, F.H., Horowitz, R., Pierce, M.C. 2014. The use of ultrasound to detect occult or unsuspected fractures in child abuse. Pediatr Emerg Care 30(1): 43-6.
Weinberg, E.R., Tunik, M.G., Tsung, J.W. 2010. Accuracy of clinician-performed point-of-care ultrasound for the diagnosis of fractures in children and young adults. Injury. 41(8): 862-8.
